Thursday, September 23, 2010

Ariel: The Time-Bomb Goes Off

This week-end, the so-called settlements moratorium runs out, and the talks face--so the argument goes--their first moment of truth. Today, at the UN, President Obama called on Israel to extend the moratorium and, pushing on an open door, is rallying international opinion, the Quartet, etc., to this position. His fear, clearly, is that Abbas will walk out of the room. Netanyahu's fear is that Leiberman and/or Shas will walk out of a different room; and so his US Ambassador is trying to rally organized American Jews to prepare for the prospect of "pressure."

I don't mean to underestimate the importance of this moment. The issue of settlements has become symbolic of whether or not Netanyahu, bowing to American diplomacy, and the looming threat of economic isolation, will be prepared to move from the status quo. Nor should anyone doubt that the status quo works in favor of the settlers and their supporters, freeze or no freeze. But as I have said in this blog before, the issue itself, at least as it is posed most commonly, is overblown and even a little misleading.

THE REAL QUESTION is whether Abbas and Netanyahu can quickly get to an agreement in principle on a new border, since various negotiations over the past 10 years have gotten everyone used to the idea that the major settlement blocs around Jerusalem and Gush Etzion will be incorporated into Israel; and that a future Palestinian state will be compensated, one-for-one, with territory that is now part of Israel.

Moreover, we are talking about two city-states that are--I know I have said this often, but we can't hear it enough--about the size of greater Los Angeles: one business ecosystem, commercial relations built on networks and knowledge, not agriculture; and urban planning that will be building up, not out. (Read what Salaam Fayyad says about this at this year's Clinton forum.) This means that once we finally get to a border, nobody will much care where it is. It will have importance in determining where you vote; it will have little importance in determining how you live.

The big a stumbling block, however, is the town of Ariel. Unlike the various settlements scattered across what Greater Israel types like to call Samaria, this is a town of about 15,000 people, and Israeli leaders have simply not prepared the Israeli public for its evacuation. Even the handing over of the neighborhoods of East Jerusalem to a Palestinian state poses less of a problem. When I spoke with former Prime Minister Olmert about where his own talks with Abbas broke down in 2007, he confirmed that the issue of Jerusalem could be resolved with various formulas for internationalizing the Holy Basin, but that "no Israeli Prime Minister could return Ariel."

The Palestinians, for their part, could never be expected to live with it. The problem is not just territorial contiguity. Ariel is a serious potential disruption of the kind of urban planning people like Fayyad would have to undertake to resettle hundreds of thousands of refugees and build infrastructure (rail, telecom, water, etc.) for a future economy. The Israeli government would expect to send forces to Ariel to protect its residents, say, from the periodic attacks that would surely come from radicals who are not reconciled to peace. This means that the territory from Israel to Ariel, like the current Area C, could not be consolidated under the control of Palestinian police. Indeed, this isolated town disrupts the only transportation corridor Palestine has from Jenin and Nablus to Ramallah.

Make no mistake, nothing particularly exotic is going on behind closed doors. The positioning, on the Israeli side, is political: Netanyahu's ideological blinkers, which may or may not be falling away; or the fear of inflaming settlers who simply don't want to be moved; or the grotesque but common strategic assumption that, if Israel can get Palestinians to swallow a certain unfairness, this means that regional "deterrence" is working.

In any case, we're going to be hearing more and more about Ariel over the next several months, and wondering where the poor benighted town came from. Just remember, this is an ectopic pregnancy of a town, with no commercial hinterland or proximate cultural neighbors, the ultimate hubris of Ariel Sharon, who expanded it greatly by dumping a few thousand Russian immigrants here straight from the airport--a town with a "university" whose accreditation most Israeli academics question, and a large performing arts center where hundreds of Israeli artists refuse to perform. Still, ectopic pregnancies can be fatal when they are not dealt with early.

I suggest you acquaint yourself with Ariel, and all the facts on the ground in the Palestinian West Bank, by means of this marvelous app just released by Peace Now. Start by looking at Ariel, its size and location as compared to other settlements, and in relation to the rest of Palestine. Breathe deeply, zoom in, then look again.


Y. Ben-David said...

Bernie is cutting loose with all the insults the elitist clique he belongs to employs in order to disparage Ariel and the people who live there. Some Israeli "artists" refuse to perform there, so the place should be evacuated. Russians live there...we all know how "primitive" they are (although it is okay for Canadian Bernie to take over an abandoned Arab house in Jerusalem, a place none of his ancestors lived in for centuries, if ever). Why, even President Clinton agrees with Bernie about the Russians, hinting they should go back where they came from.
"It has no commercial hinterland", which is not exactly true, there is the Barkan industrial zone next to it, although I don't know how many Ariel residents work there, in any event, many of Bernie's Jerusalem neighbors work in Tel Aviv, so what value does Jerusalem have?.
Regarding the university "whose academic credentials Israeli academics question", well, it has something like 10,000 students, one of whose graduates is my daughter who received a degree in Engineering and then obtained employment at one of Israel's top engineering firms. It also has a significant number of Arabs students (you know the type Bernie-Israeli Arab's future "entrepeneruial elite")

Bernie, you progressives really make me laugh. One could say, "yes, Ariel is a fine place with fine people and a fine university center, but, unfortunately, for the sake of peace, we may have to ask the people to leave. But, like many Israeli "progressives", you seem to ooze contempt for everyone who disagrees with you. They are "stupid", they are "primitive", they are "cultural philistines" who have no right to exist. That is why you are always lamenting that the wrong parties are always winning the elections, so that those who are in opposition to your views should have their political power neutralized or, ideally, have their right to vote abolished. "If only Obama would send troops here in order to take control!"
Fortunately, the large majority of Israelis have stopped listing to the siren song you people have been directing at us for 20 or more years. Everything you predicted has failed, so maybe you could embark on some serious self-reflection on all your mistaken beliefs.

David said...

One very questionable statement slaps the reader:

"This means that once we finally get to a border, nobody will much care where it is. It will have importance to determine where you vote; it will have little importance in determining how you live."

Not if Israel continues to control airspace, water, wireless, and Palestine is anything less than a fully sovereign nation.

Potter said...

It's about time we focus on Ariel, I agree. We have just prevented a relative from moving there. The main attraction was the need to be near to Tel Aviv for work opportunities while not being able to afford housing within the green line.

beautytips said...

wow nice post! i like this and everybody know about trading, you know
about trading, trading tips, live news, anouncements, quotations...more
from here

ekle paylas said...

nice blog Thanks for sharing. voicesohbet was really very nice.
sesli chat siteleri sesli sohbet
sesli sohbet siteleri sesli chat
seslichat seslisohbet
sesli siteleri chat siteleri
sohbet siteleri sesli siteler
voice sohbet sesli sohbet siteleri
sesli sohbet seslisohbet
sohbet siteleri sesli chat siteleri
seslichat sesli chat
herkesburda herkes burda
sohbetmerkezi sohbetmerkezi